Matthew 18:8-9 Cut It Off and Throw It Away

“And if your hand or your foot causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away.”  Jesus in Matthew 18:8

“(The) Son is exalted when we cherish him above all things, especially when ‘all things’ are about to be snatched from us, including our life on earth,” (John Piper, Filling up the Afflictions of Christ, p. 82).  

"This man at the back of the knave started tearing at his face and I realized he was gouging out his eyes…I carried on celebrating Mass but a lot of people had left because they were so shocked.” (Father Lorenzo Tanganelli, speaking of a man who took these verses literally near Pisa, Italy; www.nbcnewyork.com October 3, 2011)

As Jesus teaches in Matthew chapter 18 about the seriousness of sin, he turns the focus to the individual in these two verses.   Not only should we not be a stumbling block to others, we should separate ourselves from those things and activities that cause us to sin.    Jesus said, “And if your hand or your foot causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away.  It is better for you to enter life crippled or lame than with two hands or two feet to be thrown into the eternal fire.  And if your eye causes you to sin, tear it out and throw it away.  It is better for you to enter life with one eye than with two eyes to be thrown into the hell of fire” (v. 8-9).  

A similar teaching in Matthew’s gospel appears in 5:29-30.   It is important to note that preceding those verses is the teaching that the heart, not the action, is the root of sin (see 5:21-22; 27-28; see also Mark 7:21-22). Additionally, if we did pluck out our eye then “the church would be,” according to Bryant Wright our pastor in Atlanta, “full of one-eyed sinners.”  Nowhere in Scripture does the early church literally model cutting off a hand or tearing out an eye.  It is incorrect to isolate Jesus’ words here and conclude that sin is only skin-deep.

But these verses about cutting off hands and poking out eyes are a part of Holy Scripture.  Therefore we must pursue their meaning since “All Scripture is inspired by God…” (2 Timothy 3:16).  Their meaning is found when one realizes Jesus frequently used hyperbole, employing exaggerations and even impossibilities, in order to stress a teaching point (i.e., “moving mountains” in 17:20 or a camel going through “the eye of a needle” in 19:24). 

Our lives on earth are temporary yet our relationship with Jesus will last forever.  What are the idols in our lives that keep us from living with an eternal perspective or finding our deepest joy in Christ?  Let’s identify them and sever them.  Those idols can take many forms for us today.  They may be materialistic, political or lifestyle pursuits that become a greater passion to us than Christ and His kingdom.  I have heard recently about a pastor who told his congregation to delete their facebook accounts because the rekindling of old romantic relationships via facebook was destroying marriages within his church.    “If facebook causes you to sin…”

What about TV or the internet?  Food or sports?  Money, sex and power?  Do we create boundaries in our lives to protect us from “the sin which so easily entangles us” (Hebrews 12:1, NASB)?   I installed accountability software on our family computers because I know all to well the lure of dark places.   I want our family’s joy and treasure to be in the Lord.  Therefore I want to cut away any stumbling block that may hinder my family or me.

Stephen Arteburn in his excellent book, Every Man’s Battle, says there are three “gates” that we must guard in our pursuit of purity.  We must guard our eye gate (what we see), our mind gate (what we think), and our heart gate (what we adore).  These are valuable tools for me as I am confronted daily by the world’s temptations. 

Even though this passage uses hyperbole, there is one part of this passage that is not a hyperbole:  eternal fire.  The Greek word for hell is gehenna, which in turn comes from the Hebrew for “Valley of Hinnon” a ravine used for garbage that was continually burning, located just outside Jerusalem. Therefore some argue that Jesus is merely referencing a trash dump and not a literally place of eternal judgment.   Yet the theme of the eternal fire of hell is found throughout Scripture. (See Isaiah 66:24, Mark 9:43, 48; Matthew 3:12, 25:46; Revelation 20:10, 14-15).

The point of this passage is that sin has severe consequences.  These consequences are so dire that a loving God humbled himself and paid the price for our sin in his body.  Yet those who have rejected God’s provision will justly be thrown into the hell of fire. May we not forsake our Lord’s teaching and may we treasure him above all treasures.  May we cut away any branch that fails to lead us to a deeper knowledge of our greatest joy, our Lord! 

Matthew 18:7: Sin and the Ultimate Stumbling Block

“Woe to the world for temptations to sin!” Jesus in Matthew 18:7

“My tour is a religious experience!  I'm teaching people to worship themselves."  (Lady Gaga; interviewed May 13, 2011) 

 “I had motives for not wanting the world to have a meaning…Those who detect no meaning in the world generally do so because, for one reason or another, it suits their books that the world should be meaningless,” (Aldous Huxley quoted by Ravi Zacharias in his book, Can Man Live Without God? p. 30)

After being asked by His disciples, “Who is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven?” (v. 1), Jesus gives a passionate message stretching over all of chapter 18 about how His children should treat and take care of one another.  Jesus said, “Woe to the world for temptations to sin!” (v.7).  Woe means here “how greatly one will suffer!”  The Greek word for temptations to sin is skandalon, which the NASB translates “stumbling block.”  Sin is not some medieval antiquated religious term.  Our Lord attaches very dire consequences to sin and gives provocative exhortations to avoid sin.  He uses terms such as drowning and eternal fire as a way to emphasize just how serious stumbling blocks are.

And ultimately, in the greatest act of love, justice, mercy and power that our universe has ever seen, Jesus offers himself as the sacrifice for our sin.  While “fools mock at sin,” Proverbs 14:9 (NASB), our Lord took sin very seriously.  In order to remedy its effects on man and creation, he emptied himself of all his divinity in order to make payment for our sin. 

Romans 14:13 teaches us to never “put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother.”   We are free to eat and drink whatever we want but if that freedom causes one of his little ones to stumble, then we are “no longer walking in love,” (Romans 14:15).  James also warns us against causing others to stumble because of the words we say (see James 3:1-12).    May we not destroy with our food (or drink or words) “the one for whom Christ died,” (Romans 14:15).

Jesus continues, “For it is necessary that temptations come,” (v. 7).  This is a difficult statement.  Why is it necessary that temptations come?  It seems it would be easier to walk with God in a world where there were no stumbling blocks, no temptations to sin.   But what seems right to man may not be right in God’s eyes.  Scripture says that part of the process of becoming more Christ-like is to confront sin in the power of the Holy Spirit. 

Consider Romans 5:3-5: “Not only that, but we rejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, and hope does not put us to shame, because God's love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us.”  James 1:2-4 teaches, “Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, for you know that the testing of your faith produces steadfastness. And let steadfastness have its full effect, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing.”  Jesus teaches in a parable that to root up the evil weeds would actually damage the good wheat, (see 13:29).

Temptations will come; it is inevitable.  But woe to the one by whom temptation comes!  (v. 7) Woe to the one who has quenched the Spirit’s work and has hardened himself to sin and been given over to it (Romans 1:28).  He may gloat in the idea that he has thwarted God.   But this is not true!  God, in his holiness and sovereignty will now use him, even as an instrument of evil, to strengthen his saints and accomplish his plans.   No man will turn aside God.

From Joseph’s brothers to Pharaoh to the chief priests and Judas to Satan’s minions at Armageddon, God will ultimately use for his glory those whose intent is to put stumbling blocks before man. “It is he (God) who sits above the circle of the earth…who brings princes to nothing and makes the rulers of the earth as emptiness,” (Isaiah 40:22-23).

It is not just the meandering rock stars or the rulers of earth who can make his little ones stumble.  We too must embrace these warnings for ourselves.  Let us be careful what we say, what we drink, what we post on social media, what we wear or the kind of persona we try to present to others.   Yes, we have freedom in Christ, but are we encouraging others in their walks with God through our everyday lives?  These are hard lessons to learn. 

Lets also remember that Jesus Christ is the ultimate stumbling block for those who refuse his invitation.   For the redeemed, Christ is our fortress, our shield and our strong tower (see Psalm 18:2).   Yet the Cornerstone of our faith has become “the stone that the builders have rejected,” (Psalm 118:22).    May we find our rock and refuge in Christ! 

Matthew 18:5-6 Jesus’ Passion for His Little Ones

“Whoever receives one such child in my name receives me,” Jesus in Matthew 18:5

"We’re not going to let a child in our county be without a mom or dad for a night, without someone who will care for them and love on them,”  (David Platt, author of Radical, explaining his church’s efforts to cover the entire need for foster families in Shelby county Alabama where the church is located; www.thealabamabaptist.org in a post dated November 19, 2009) 

One of the great movements within Christianity that I have seen is a renewed emphasis on adoption and foster parenting.   My good friend Gary Gaddini, a pastor in Redwood City, California, and his wife Anne recently adopted a little girl from the Democratic Republic of Congo.  Gary explained to me the spiritual significance of adoption and how it reflects the work of God in a Christian’s life: we were lost, without a home, dwelling in darkness.  Yet God chose us, gave us a new identity and adopted us into his family.  

Adoption is a beautiful act of mercy that is also a picture of a spiritual reality.  Additionally adoption is living in light of Jesus’ words in verse 5: “Whoever receives one such child in my name receives me.”  However there is still a broader meaning to this verse.  Jesus is describing what humility, mentioned in the previous verse (v. 4), looks like.   He is speaking of our need to receive in his name those who have humbled themselves like a child.   Receiving one such child is receiving Christ himself.   

This is not about salvation but it is about how we treat those loved by Christ.  Jesus affectionately uses words for those within his church that imply family as well as words that imply he personally identifies with them.    For example, Christ equates the phrase “little ones” with “disciple.” (10:42).   And again he says, “as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me,” (25:40; see also 25:45).

Contrastingly, Jesus says, “Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea,” (v. 6).    A millstone is a large circular stone that was used to grind grain.   Some were so big that a donkey was needed to rotate the millstone. Millstones were so vital to the lives of those during Bible times that one of the Mosaic laws said “no one shall take a …millstone in pledge, for that would be taking a life in pledge,” (Deuteronomy 24:6). 

My wife EB with a millstone in the Garden Tomb in Jerusalem, 2011

Jesus uses near superlative language to construct a metaphor (i.e., great millstone, better…to be drowned, depth of the sea) to communicate the seriousness of causing his little ones to stumble.  D. A. Carson, in his commentary on Matthew, says this metaphor is “the horror of judgment sharpened.”

Our Lord is so passionate for his flock that he lays down his life for his sheep (see John 10:11).    It would do us well to heed the instruction of our Lord as he explains throughout chapter 18 how his sheep should treat one another. We are to love, care, forgive, pursue, nurture and protect each other as well as we must put aside our power plays and egos.  The seriousness of Jesus’ words here should make us tremble.

I fear for those who have used peer pressure, fame, authority, influence and other platforms to destroy the faith of his children.   Dr. William Dembski, a college professor well-known for his work in Intelligent Design, in a 2008 interview warns of unbelieving college biology professors whose intent is to use “biology, especially evolutionary biology, as an ideological weapon to destroy faith in God.”

Yet I must also examine myself.  When have I said a careless word that causes one of these little ones who believe in him to stumble?  When have I acted in a haughty way that enticed a young believer away from the path of God?  For I too am now guilty of causing one of his little ones to sin.   Yet praise God for the gospel of grace.   His forgiveness is available to all who want it and it is greater than all our sin.  

Matthew 18:4: Greatest in the Kingdom

“Whoever humbles himself like this child is greatest in the kingdom of heaven,” Jesus in Matthew 18:4

“…for me it is success and drivenness and it is productivity and it is victory that drives me constantly. I – that’s my own little idol and it works well in a church because no one would ever yell at you for being a Christian who produces results.”  (Words from a 2006 sermon from the pastor of a church once known as “the fastest growing church in America.”  To his credit, the pastor has since stepped away from this attitude)

“The cause of Christ is greatly dependent on the self-forgetting souls who are satisfied to occupy a small sphere in an obscure place, free from self-seeking ambition.”  (John MacArthur, Commentary on Matthew 8-15)

Jesus is in Capernaum (see 16:24) on his way to Jerusalem (see 16:21) mindful that there he will be given over to evil men.   His disciples cannot quite fathom all this, at least not yet.   They are more concerned about other things (i.e., themselves) and ask Jesus, “Who is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven?” (v. 1) Instead of lining the disciples up from greatest to least, Jesus does something totally unexpected. He puts a child “in the midst of them” (v. 3).

Jesus says, “Whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven,” (v. 4).  This statement is counter-cultural!  It is hard-wired into our fallen natures to be self-sufficient, prideful and to strive to be number one.   Yes, there is a place for excellence in our world today.   But that is not what Jesus is teaching about here.   Also, this is a dangerous topic for me to teach on.  The moment one props himself up as a teacher on humility, he just may have disqualified himself from being humble.   Yet as we walk through Matthew’s gospel together, let’s try to grasp what our Lord is teaching, knowing all of us need grace everyday in our walks with God.

Jesus tells a parable in Luke’s gospel contrasting two men who went to the temple to pray.  The first, a Pharisee who thanked God he was not like all the other losers around him.  Then to further the distance even more between him and the low-lifes, the Pharisee rattled off his list of religious deeds.   But the second man would not even lift his eyes to heaven and cried out, “God be merciful to me, a sinner!” Jesus condemns the first man and says,  “For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled but the one who humbles himself will be exalted,” (Luke 18:14). 

While on a trip to Africa we heard a story from one the clinics that Christian friends of ours operated.  A woman failed to birth a son for her Muslim husband and birthed a handicapped daughter instead.  He divorced her on the spot and left her alone to care for their daughter.   Shame and failure should not be tolerated is the lesson here. 

And as Americans we too struggle with our pride.  In the American church we value achievement and growth over child-like faith.   Too many pastors are more like celebrities and CEOs, than shepherds and servants; our churches are more like enterprises and businesses than flocks and families.  Can one find a Christian book where praise for the author and a list of his achievements are not printed on the dust jacket or back cover?

As I type this it is a hot summer afternoon.   I can hear the sounds of children playing at a nearby swimming pool.   I hear laughter, splashing and rapid conversation.   For me this is an audio picture of how Jesus spoke of humility.   Our God loves us not because we work hard or produce more.  God loves us simply because he chooses to love us.   Warts and all.   Sin and all.   And he wants us to rest in that love.   This is difficult to learn, as it was for the disciples, because we all want to prove our worth and call attention to our successes.  

The greatest in the kingdom of heaven will not be those who are famous on earth.   Fame and humility rarely mix.  Those greatest in the kingdom of heaven will likely be those we have never heard of; missionaries and pastors who labored faithfully yet anonymously, those who endured great trials yet constantly put their hope in God in spite of their difficult circumstances.    Or simply those who enjoyed life, not because everything was perfect but because, like a child, they rested, played and worshiped in the continual presence of their heavenly Father.